The latest run in the Dow has Bill Fleckenstein looking back at the final days of the Nikkei’s rise in 1989:
Recently, I decided to revisit a chart of Japan’s Nikkei index from 1989. What prompted me were comments by GMO Chairman Jeremy Grantham that, for America’s current stock bubble to burst, it may need to go parabolic, a la Tokyo 1989.
When I read that, I thought: Wait, the Nikkei did not go parabolic at the end in 1989. I was short that market in 1989 and held long-dated put warrants, so I followed it quite closely. In the final five months before its crash, the Nikkei was almost orderly, rallying about 20%. By contrast, the Nasdaq Composite Index ($COMPX) nearly doubled in the last five months before the 2000 crash.
In any case, after a little checking, I did find an amazing similarity between the last month or so of the rise in Japan that ended on Dec. 29, 1989, and the current advance in the Dow Jones Industrial Average ($INDU) (through April 27): Specifically, the last 32 out of 38 trading days in Tokyo were on the upside, with an initial run with a higher close on 19 out of 21 days, followed by seven out of 11, followed by six for six before about a 40% drop in the course of nine months took place. Recently, from the lows of March 5, the Dow closed higher in four out of six sessions, followed by seven out of 11, followed by 20 out of 22 — for a grand total of 31 out of 39 days.
Now, I am not a big believer in analogs, but if the mind-set in Tokyo back in those days was similar to the mind-set that we’re witnessing here today, which, by my reckoning, it is, I guess it’s not impossible for that similarity to have some predictive power.
I’m not putting up any money on the back of this idea just yet. But I thought it was so interesting, I wanted to have it on my radar screen, and I assumed others would, as well.
We’ll see, won’t we? Regular readers know that Fleck has been waiting for the “next time down” to start for quite a while now. And it’ll start - someday. The problem is, none of us will ever know when, until it’s well underway.
Also interesting that Fleck would bring up 1989 - isn’t that the year that Scott Bleier was comparing the current environment to as well?